Where Real Estate Gets Its Dirt

Anywhere but Manhattan

Brooklee Han for Housing Wire:

Why Compass wants the MLS antitrust dispute out of New York

“The MLSs characterize Compass’s pre‑suit communications differently, saying the company presented only two options: abandon their cooperation rules entirely in exchange for what they describe as a “toothless” release that left them under a “perpetual threat” of future litigation, or face antitrust lawsuits without clarity as to timing or venue.”

Sounds like the title of a Woody Allen movie. But here’s the deal, Compass is headquartered in New York. When it wanted to stop Zillow’s listing access standards, it sued in the Southern District of New York. It lost the injunction in February, with the judge warning these practices could “encourage freeriding; fragment the real estate market; and limit transparency.” Compass later dropped the case.

So now that seven MLSs have asked that same courthouse to bless their cooperation rules, Compass would like to be anywhere (pardon the pun) else. Arizona, Northern California, Colorado, both ends of North Carolina. Anywhere it has already filed its own suit, which by HousingWire’s count is about 15 cases in 11 districts.

The argument is that these MLSs are independent: separate boards, separate markets, different rules. A shared adversary and a similar form letter, Compass says, don’t make one case. I’ll give them the separate boards. But that form letter was Compass’s. One letter, one demand, one release to sign. Compass ran the national campaign. Now it wants each MLS tried at home, one courtroom at a time.

Here’s why that matters. One judge looking at seven MLSs’ cooperation rules side by side produces one answer. A dozen judges produce a dozen, and it seems to me Compass only needs one of them to go its way to have something to wave at every other MLS in the country. The MLSs call it a recipe for inconsistent rulings and “massive inefficiencies.” I’d call it the strategy.

Venue fights sound like lawyer stuff. This one is the whole ballgame. If cooperation gets decided once, the industry gets an answer and every MLS can plan around it. If it gets decided district by district, we get a patchwork, and MLSs start rewriting rules one bad ruling at a time.

Keep it in Manhattan. Compass liked it there fine when it was suing Zillow.

Leave a Reply

Sponsored By Paragon Connect