Yesterday I said Compass wanted this case anywhere but Manhattan. It now has a date to make that argument, and it does not get to rehearse it first. Judge Mary Kay Vyskocil denied Compass’s request for a pre-motion conference, left the briefing schedule where it was, and gave Compass until December 3 to file. Then she left a footnote:
refrain from filing seriatim updates on each and every development in this wide-ranging litigation.
I had to look up what “seriatim” meant. Bottom line, both sides have been papering the docket with letters. The court has read enough of them.
One correction to my post yesterday. It is nine MLSs, not seven. There are two cases. CRMLS filed October 5 and picked up OneKey on the 27th. ARMLS filed October 21 with bridgeMLS, Canopy, Doorify, Hive and REcolorado, then added MLSListings on the 30th. HousingWire covered one case and RISMedia covered the other, which is how everybody, me included, ended up at seven. OneKey is now a plaintiff in one of these cases and a defendant in one of Compass’s fifteen. Confused yet?
And one addition, because the independence argument looks worse than it did yesterday. ARMLS’s side says three of the MLSs Compass sued, Bay East, Contra Costa and NorthstarMLS, never got a demand letter. Unlock MLS got one, rejected it publicly in October, and is not among the fifteen. The letter list and the defendant list are not the same list. For fifteen separate local disputes, that is a strange way to pick the locals.
So many great candidates! Top Row, Left to Right: Jon Druse, Michael Hayes, Nina Dosanjh. Second Row, Left to Right: Angie Baker, Steve Byrd, Daniel Jones, Alireza Memar. Third Row, Left to Right: Cindy Miller, Greg Moore, Richard Renton.
The nominees were all asked to submit answers to the following questions regarding their vision and what they will contribute to RESO. Their answers can be found on the election website.
What are the three most important priorities or initiatives that RESO should pursue during the next two years?
How do you see your contributions as a board member being utilized for realizing these priorities?
What is your current/past involvement in RESO workgroups?
Are you willing and able to meet the time requirements to serve as a director for a two-year term?
Each RESO member organization may cast one vote. The ballot will be sent to the primary contact on your account. If you are not sure who that is, or if you need to make a change to your primary contact, email support@reso.org.
Voting is from November 16 at 7:00 am (PT) to November 30 at 11:59 pm (PT).
“The MLSs characterize Compass’s pre‑suit communications differently, saying the company presented only two options: abandon their cooperation rules entirely in exchange for what they describe as a “toothless” release that left them under a “perpetual threat” of future litigation, or face antitrust lawsuits without clarity as to timing or venue.”
Sounds like the title of a Woody Allen movie. But here’s the deal, Compass is headquartered in New York. When it wanted to stop Zillow’s listing access standards, it sued in the Southern District of New York. It lost the injunction in February, with the judge warning these practices could “encourage freeriding; fragment the real estate market; and limit transparency.” Compass later dropped the case.
So now that seven MLSs have asked that same courthouse to bless their cooperation rules, Compass would like to be anywhere (pardon the pun) else. Arizona, Northern California, Colorado, both ends of North Carolina. Anywhere it has already filed its own suit, which by HousingWire’s count is about 15 cases in 11 districts.
The argument is that these MLSs are independent: separate boards, separate markets, different rules. A shared adversary and a similar form letter, Compass says, don’t make one case. I’ll give them the separate boards. But that form letter was Compass’s. One letter, one demand, one release to sign. Compass ran the national campaign. Now it wants each MLS tried at home, one courtroom at a time.
Here’s why that matters. One judge looking at seven MLSs’ cooperation rules side by side produces one answer. A dozen judges produce a dozen, and it seems to me Compass only needs one of them to go its way to have something to wave at every other MLS in the country. The MLSs call it a recipe for inconsistent rulings and “massive inefficiencies.” I’d call it the strategy.
Venue fights sound like lawyer stuff. This one is the whole ballgame. If cooperation gets decided once, the industry gets an answer and every MLS can plan around it. If it gets decided district by district, we get a patchwork, and MLSs start rewriting rules one bad ruling at a time.
Keep it in Manhattan. Compass liked it there fine when it was suing Zillow.
“Compass wants to take, not give. It’s suing 16 MLSs to see competitors’ listings while holding back its own, and nine MLSs are suing it back. Its arguments shift depending on what helps it commercially.”
Great analysis from Jonathan Miller on his Housing Notes Substack. His points about how Compass is using the fact that most consumers don’t know what an MLS actually does is spot on:
“Then I discovered that Compass-Anywhere had also been blocking Housing Notes from any of their agents who signed up with their company email address, but they never told them. For a company that claims to care about “choice” (apparently as long as it’s their choice), Compass has no qualms about deleting a housing market resource their agents chose without telling them. I have never heard of a real estate brokerage censoring its own agents’ email subscriptions in my career.”
The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player!
Overview
Rob and Greg look at the four new MLS policy recommendations from NAR’s Multiple Listing Issues and Policies Committee and end up in one of their most heated debates yet. Most of it is about a new optional policy that lets MLSs require brokers to assign up to 50% of the copyright in listing photos and descriptions. Greg points to support from CRMLS, the Realty Alliance and a unanimous board vote. Rob calls the policy a giant mistake and argues for a voluntary, opt-in program based on the ASCAP/BMI model instead. They also argue about new qualifications for NAR MLS committee members, which leads Rob to propose that NAR hand MLS policy over to CMLS entirely. The episode opens with a preview of a future topic: whether the new American dream is being able to afford to live near your family.
Key Takeaways
Rob suggests a future topic: can multiple generations of a family afford to live in the same community?
Rob sees NAR’s optional MLS data-feed policy as political cover for things MLSs already do.
The new data-use policy bans uses not allowed by participation agreements, which Rob says those agreements already cover.
The revised Policy 7.85 says brokers must own or have authority to license their listing content.
A new optional policy lets MLSs require participants to assign up to 50% of the copyright in photos and descriptions, with an opt-out.
CRMLS (Art Carter, Ed Zorn) proposed the copyright policy, and the Realty Alliance (Craig Cheatham) endorsed it.
Greg backs it as an industry-wide answer to scraping and AI misuse.
Rob says brokers can already assign rights voluntarily, so making it a condition of participation is the mistake.
Rob urges MLSs to ignore the policy and look into the ASCAP/BMI collective rights model.
New NAR MLS committee qualifications include real estate tech familiarity, MLS/association leadership, and training such as CMLX.
Rob argues “real estate technology” isn’t the same as MLS expertise.
Rob proposes that NAR leave MLS policy to CMLS and that CMLS hand lobbying to NAR.
Search and reporting are where most people first notice AI in real estate. They are also just the starting point. MLS organizations have an opportunity to tap into using AI in ways that go beyond platform search, helping agents work smarter, improving data quality and creating a more personalized experience for everyone involved.
Here are three areas where AI can make a practical difference across MLS technology:
1. Predictive market insights
Timing matters in real estate, and AI can help MLSs, brokers and agents see shifts sooner. By analyzing historical trends, current conditions, and outside factors such as interest rates and economic indicators, AI can help surface patterns that are often easy to miss.
Consider a neighborhood where inventory is tightening ahead of a price increase, or an area where search and engagement data point to rising buyer demand. Insights like these are actionable. Agents can use them to refine pricing strategies, advise clients with more confidence and adjust marketing while conditions are still changing.
For MLSs, the same analytics can inform strategic planning by showing where the market is heading and how the platform can best serve its members.
2. Conversational tools and voice search
MLS platforms are powerful, but they can be challenging to navigate, particularly for newer agents or anyone working across several systems. AI-powered virtual assistants can offer a simpler way in. They can walk a user through entering a listing, adjusting a search filter or finding a specific report at any hour.
Voice search is also becoming increasingly popular. An agent between showings could ask for “three-bedroom homes in Riverside under $500K” and see results right away, without typing. Features like these make the MLS platform easier to use, encourage adoption, and help it feel current and responsive.
3. Fraud detection and risk management
Confidence in listing data is central to how an MLS operates. AI can help protect it by monitoring for unusual activity, such as sudden and unexplained price changes, duplicate entries or patterns that suggest manipulation.
It can also support agent verification by flagging inconsistent credentials or irregular login behavior that may point to impersonation. As platforms connect to more systems and data moves between them, safeguards like these become more important. Identifying risk early helps MLSs maintain data integrity, protect users, and support compliance without adding to staff workload.
Why it matters
Each of these use cases benefit the whole real estate ecosystem: MLSs, agents, brokers and consumers. Agents and brokers can spend more time on client relationships, consumers get a better experience, and platforms become more intuitive and efficient. MLSs that explore AI thoughtfully will be better positioned to lead on innovation and collaboration as the industry evolves.
See why more than 200 MLS organizations across the U.S. trust Paragon Connect to provide best-in-class real estate solutions to help their members work faster, smarter and stand out.
“A Compass spokesperson described the latest lawsuits to Inman as a follow-through on Reffkin’s warnings at the Council of Multiple Listing Services’ annual conference in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, in late September, noting that some MLS organizations had filed their own lawsuits before Compass took legal action.”
“Wounded Warrior Project’s mental health programs include WWP Talk, which calls warriors and family members each week, and Warrior Care Network, which provides intensive outpatient treatment through four academic medical centers, according to the organization.”
Sam, Kevin and I are really honored by the coverage at Inman News gave us on this special day. So, we decided to re-launch the promo we did back in September by giving all profits from book sales this week to the Wounded Warriors project.
The Industry Relations Podcast is now available on your favorite podcast player!
Overview Rob and Greg are back from the NAR annual convention in New Orleans. They talk about lower attendance, whether NAR committee meetings should be open to members and the press, and Compass’s new policy barring its W-2 employees from NAR volunteer leadership roles. Greg shares what he heard in 14 meetings with MLS executives about OpenRE, and the hosts disagree over whether OpenRE is a national data repository, a listing input tool, or mostly a lobbying effort. They close with their favorite conversations from the convention.
Key Takeaways
NAR attendance fell from over 30,000 in past years to about 10,000 this year.
Greg blames a perfect storm: the lingering effects of COVID, a down market, and infighting within the industry.
Rob suggests NAR could focus only on business (votes and committee meetings) and open those meetings to members and the press.
Greg points out that companies commonly keep the press out of strategy meetings.
Compass now bars its W-2 employees from NAR volunteer leadership positions.
Rob sees the policy as a way to reduce antitrust risk, not as retaliation against NAR.
Greg thinks announcing it during the NAR convention was gamesmanship.
The policy could affect NAR First Vice President Jennifer Branchini’s path to the presidency.
MLS execs placed OpenRE somewhere between “nothing burger” and “distraction.”
MLS execs say they understand brokers’ frustrations and are open to working with them.
Greg believes the real broker pain point is double entry across multiple MLSs, which is a problem BLX could solve.
Greg wonders when Cotality might acquire Ocusell.
A broker consortium might reach about 30% of a market’s data, while the MLS has all of it.
Portals want complete, checked, ad-quality listings, and they doubt OpenRE can deliver that.
Rob argues OpenRE either adds little value or would end up replacing the MLS.
Greg gives OpenRE about a 10% chance of success and warns against reading too much into so few details.
Q1 will show whether OpenRE is a real company or just a press release.
One MLS has over 30 active status types, an example of how complex listing data is.
When most people think about buying or selling a home, they think about agents, open houses, and mortgage rates. But every consumer portal, appraisal, mortgage underwrite runs on MLS data.
Earlier this year, Lucie Fortier, Head of MLS Solutions for ICE Mortgage Technology, discussed how the MLS is the engine behind every real estate transaction. Portals, AI tools and PropTech platforms leverage MLS data. Agents, brokers, loan officers, appraisers and more operate within an ecosystem the MLS makes possible. Without comprehensive cooperation, none of it works.
Why the system is worth protecting
The American MLS system is rare. In most countries, real estate data is fragmented, unreliable or unavailable to the average consumer. What exists here is the result of decades of cooperation among professionals who understand that a shared system serves everyone better than a fragmented one.
That’s not a small thing. It’s the foundation that everything else is built on. And it doesn’t maintain itself.
What this moment is about
New tools and platforms are only as good as the data powering them. That data lives in the MLS − and the organizations investing in it are the ones that will matter on the other side of whatever comes next.