Judge denies Compass’ request for conference in MLS lawsuits
Yesterday I said Compass wanted this case anywhere but Manhattan. It now has a date to make that argument, and it does not get to rehearse it first. Judge Mary Kay Vyskocil denied Compass’s request for a pre-motion conference, left the briefing schedule where it was, and gave Compass until December 3 to file. Then she left a footnote:
refrain from filing seriatim updates on each and every development in this wide-ranging litigation.
I had to look up what “seriatim” meant. Bottom line, both sides have been papering the docket with letters. The court has read enough of them.
One correction to my post yesterday. It is nine MLSs, not seven. There are two cases. CRMLS filed October 5 and picked up OneKey on the 27th. ARMLS filed October 21 with bridgeMLS, Canopy, Doorify, Hive and REcolorado, then added MLSListings on the 30th. HousingWire covered one case and RISMedia covered the other, which is how everybody, me included, ended up at seven. OneKey is now a plaintiff in one of these cases and a defendant in one of Compass’s fifteen. Confused yet?
And one addition, because the independence argument looks worse than it did yesterday. ARMLS’s side says three of the MLSs Compass sued, Bay East, Contra Costa and NorthstarMLS, never got a demand letter. Unlock MLS got one, rejected it publicly in October, and is not among the fifteen. The letter list and the defendant list are not the same list. For fifteen separate local disputes, that is a strange way to pick the locals.
Thirteen days. I’d still wait.